I would definitely object to those rims being called "basically brand new" if I had bought them and thats what showed up. The dings look like they are all cosmetic but still, they're pretty dinged up. Some people wouldn't care about all the nicks and lace them up and go but some people are more particular than that. As a guy that sells a lot of 50 parts around here, I would never in a million years call those rims "basically brand new" because then people expect to get stuff that really is like new.